This exercise challenges participants to make decisions and defend them to their peers. They will go through several stages of defending their decisions and then coming to consensus. At the end, they will be able to score themselves based on how well they defended each of the decisions.
- Print copies of “Courage of Your Convictions – Worksheets” (one per participant). You can download it on the Lesson and Material Downloads page at www.teachingthem.com. There are eight different worksheets to choose from. Each one will take up to an hour to complete through all four stages, so you will probably only want to use a few during any given workshop.
- Hand out colored markers (one set per participant of blue, red, yellow, green and purple markers). You can use anything colored – paper or posterboard squares, colored paperclips, manipulatives used for teaching young children, colored dots, etc.
Explaining the Exercise: 5 minutes.
Stage 1: 20 minutes
Stage 2: 10 minutes
Stage 3: 10 minutes
Stage 4: 10 minutes
Debrief: 15 minutes (Save the debrief until you have done all worksheets that you are doing to do.)
- Read through the instructions on the first page of the “Courage of Your Convictions – Worksheets” document, and then let them start discussions. (It may be best to read just Stage 1 and Stage 2 at first. Once those are completed, share Stage 3, and when that is completed, share Stage 4. When all four Stages are complete, pass out another worksheet or (if you are done) have them answer the Debrief Questions at the bottom of the first page of their worksheets document.)
- The process is as follows:
- Participants will review different scenarios and choose a response.
- Then, they will reveal their response to their peers and defend their choice.
- The group must then work toward consensus.
- Once that is achieved, groups will be mixed, and each team member must then defend the group’s decision to the new group. However, in the end, they must come to consensus.
- Participants then return to their original groups and explain what happened – adding new information and rationale to the discussion. In the end, they must come to consensus again.
- Finally, participants will grade themselves based on the number of times they changed their decisions. A high number of changes is not desirable, because it show that they were too easily influenced by the groups (and did not have the “courage of their convictions”).
- The debrief is saved until the completion of all worksheets.